Wine Picks February 16, 2008

By Natalie MacLean Print this page   Send this page to a friend

To subscribe to Natalie's Wine Reviews, click here.


White Wine


2006 Alamos Chardonnay Catena Esmeralda Mendoza, Argentina: VC: Look for layers of apple and pear fruit flavors on the palate interwoven with notes of vanilla and sweet spice imparted by the light oak aging. My note: An excellent full-bodied chardonnay with ripe tree fruit notes. 925743 13% D 750 mL $13.95 Score: 89/100. Best Value White Wine

2006 Grant Burge Wines Pty Ltd Grant Burge, Summers Chardonnay Australia: Round, buttery, full-bodied chardonnay. Closed with a screwcap. Pair with: pork, chicken, lobster. 57315 14% XD 750 mL $18.75 Score: 90/100.

2005 Pierre Sparr Pinot Gris R�serve AC Alsace, France – Alsace: VC: This Pinot Gris delivers layers of peach, melon and nut aromas that replay beautifully on the palate. This full-bodied wine shows good intensity and balance. My note: A concentrated white wine with the aromas of lychee, peach and hazelnuts. Pair with: pan-seared scallops. 983395 14% D 750 mL $18.85 Score: 90/100.

2003 M. Chapoutier S.A. Chante Alouette Bl Hermitage France – Rh�ne: A richly concentrated wine with floral and citrus notes. Pair with: chicken, pork. 140541 14% 750 mL $74.75 Score: 90/100.

2006 Prinz Salm Schloss Wallhausen Riesling Kabinett Q.M.p. Nahe, Estate Btld., Germany – Nahe: VC: Here is an excellent opportunity to discover the Rieslings of Nahe. The first mention of this acclaimed winery was in the year 1200. It has remained in the Salm family’s hands to this day, making it the oldest, continuously family-owned estate in Germany. The estate produces vibrant Rieslings with lovely aromas of lime, tangerine and mineral tones. My note: A lovely medium-bodied sipper with thrilling ripe pear and peach aromas. Pair with: pan-seared scallops. 993766 9% MD 750 mL $21.75 Score: 90/100.

2005 The Tiers Wine Co. Clarence Hill Chardonnay Mclaren Vale, South Australia: VC: In 1990, twenty-five years after emigrating to Australia from Italy with his parents, Claudio Curtis founded the Tiers Wine Company. Clarence Hill is one of three premium wines that Tiers produces. This Chardonnay displays lovely melon, peach, vanilla and toasty oak aromas. It’s dry with bright fruit flavors and measured oak notes leading to a lingering finish. My note: A robust white with buttery and pear notes. Good acidity. Pair with: apricot-glazed pork loin. 57679 14% XD 750 mL $16.95 Score: 87/100.

2004 Chateau Des Charmes Paul Bosc Estate Chardonnay Canada - Ontario: Perfectly balanced. A round white wine with buttery notes. 287268 14% XD 750 mL $19.95 Score: 90/100.

2005 Le Clos Jordanne Village Reserve Chardonnay V.Q.A. Niagara Peninsula, Canada – Ontario: Wow! Exotic pear and peaches aroma. A round, buttery and luscious wine. 33936 14% XD 750 mL $25.00 Score: 92/100. Favorite White Wine

2004 Tawse Robyn's Block Chardonnay V.Q.A. Niagara Peninsula, Canada – Ontario: A lovely, full-bodied white with ripe pear, apple, melon, butter and smoke notes. 662841 13% XD 750 mL $48.00 Score: 92/100.

2007 Babich Black Label Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough, South Island, New Zealand: VC: This exuberant Sauvignon Blanc bursts with intense floral and passion fruit aromas that lead to flavors of gooseberry, pear and melon on the refreshing palate. This is prototypical New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc with loads of personality and the promise of spring in every glass. My note: Grassy goodness. A refreshing and zippy white. Closed with a screwcap. Pair with: lemon chicken, grilled seafood. 9142 13% XD 750 mL $19.95 Score: 89/100.


Red Wine

2005 Bodegas Catena Zapata Catena Cabernet Sauvignon Mendoza, Argentina: VC: This Cabernet Sauvignon is sourced from four separate estate vineyards which are planted at elevations ranging from 945 m to 1524 m above sea level. It’s full-bodied and concentrated with layers of rich blackberry and cassis flavors layered with hints of mint, espresso and mineral notes. My note: A juicy, mouth-watering wine with pleasingly ripe aromas of plums and blackberries. 985002 13% XD 750 mL $19.95 Score: 90/100.

2005 Eral Bravo Cabernet Sauvignon Mendoza, Argentina: VC: Eral Bravo derives its name from the family tradition of breeding Iberic bulls. Eral is the name given to the bull when he begins displaying his essential characteristics of bravado. The winery had a bull year in 2007, taking home a number of medals at the first annual Wines of Argentina Awards including a Silver for this Cab. It’s bold, with a deep inky color, ripe blackcurrant fruit, toasty oak notes and a rich, full body. My note: This wine has aromas of sweet black fruit and oak. Pair with: rare beef dishes. 58081 14% XD 750 mL $18.55 Score: 89/100.

2005 Bodega Valentin Bianchi Famiglia Cabernet Sauvignon San Rafael, Mendoza, Argentina: This incredibly concentrated wine has rich aromas of blackberry and plum. 677567 14% XD 750 mL $13.95 Score: 90/100. Best Value Red Wine

2006 Zilzie Shiraz South Eastern Australia, Honkin' big shiraz with aromas of cherry liqueur and plum fruit. 58016 14% XD 750 mL $16.75 Score: 89/100.

2004 Saltram of Barossa Mamre Brook Cabernet Sauvignon Barossa, South Australia, Australia: A delicious, full-bodied red wine with notes of black plums and blackberries. 48579 14% XD 750 mL $19.90 Score: 90/100.

2005 D’Arenberg The High Trellis Cabernet Sauvignon Mclaren Vale, South Australia, This full-bodied wine has aromas of black plums and mint. Pair with: steak, stew, roast. 943456 14% XD 750 mL $20.95 Score: 89/100.

2005 Montes Alpha Cabernet Sauvignon Apalta Vineyard, Colchagua Valley, Chile: This red wine possesses lovely layers of black plums, cedar and dried herbs. Pair with: steak. 322586 14% XD 750 mL $21.80 Score: 90/100.

2005 Morand� Cabernet Sauvignon Reserva Maipo Valley, Chile: VC: The fruit for this Cab comes from the Santa Laura Vineyard in the Maipo Valley. It has an attractive nose full of red fruit and berries and is rich on the palate with spice notes complementing the intense fruit flavors. My note: A full-bodied red wine with notes of black plums and cedar. Fantastic value. Pair with: red meat, barbecue, pasta marinara, pasta. 57984 13% D 750 mL $13.85 Score: 89/100.

2005 Santa Rita Medalla Real Reserva Especial Cabernet Sauvignon Maipo Valley, Chile: VC: A consistent overachiever, the 2005 promises to impress as well with its rich and concentrated flavors of blackcurrants, smoky oak and sweet herbs. My note: A wonderful concentration of black fruit and smoke. Pair with: roasted, game meats, venison. 275594 14% XD 750 mL $19.90 Score: 91/100.

2005 Yvon Mau et Fils Ch�teau Lalande Les Moulins AC St-Julien, France – Bordeaux: VC: Run by two young men from a family with a long history of winemaking, Ch�teau Lalande Les Moulins is a dynamic, up-and-coming St-Julien winery. Ludovic and Julien Meffre, two scions of a Rh�ne-based wine family, took over the running of the estate a mere seven years ago. Following in their grandfather’s footsteps, who first purchased the property in 1964, the Meffre brothers have introduced many refinements both in the vineyard and the winery to substantially improve the quality of the fruit and thus the finished wine. Enjoy this fruit-forward, yet perfectly structured wine from the great 2005 vintage. It will also reward 4-6 years in a cellar. My note: A deep red wine with concentrated aromas of black fruit and smoke. Pair with: rare steak, steak, lamb. 61036 13% XD 750 mL $29.95 Score: 90/100. Favorite Red Wine

2006 J. Fran�ois Fayel, Prop.-R�colt. Domaine Des Cantarelles Rouge AC Costi�res De N�mes, France – Midi: VC: Costi�res de N�mes is located in the far eastern section of Languedoc. In fact, it is also very close to the Southern Rh�ne so, stylistically, the wines tend to have the ripe fruit of the Midi and the structure one typically finds in the Rh�ne. This wine is a blend of, principally, Syrah and Grenache. It shows ripe fruit tones with a cedary structure for ageing. My note: A dark brooding wine with notes of oak and black fruit. Pleasant bitter finish. Pair with: grilled steak, onions. 61275 13% XD 750 mL $13.75 Score: 86/100.

2006 Alain Boisson Domaine Cros De Romet Cairanne AC C�tes Du Rh�ne-Village, France – Rh�ne: VC: Domaine Cros de Romet’s Cairanne is a blend of 80% Grenache and 20% Syrah. It is matured exclusively in stainless steel in order to retain its characteristic bright fruitiness. The 2006 is filled with blackberry, sour cherry and plum flavors with a hint of pepper appearing on the finish to balance it off nicely. My note: A delicious, lip-smacking, full-bodied red wine with aromas of plums and blackberries. Decant for 1-2 hours. Pair with: braised beef, beef, roast leg of lamb. 42986 16% XD 750 mL $17.85 Score: 87/100.

2004 Alazard P�re & Fils Domaine De La Colline Saint-Jean Vacqueyras AC, France – Rh�ne – Southern Rh�ne: A rich, deep red wine with cherry liquor and cassis notes. 38661 14% XD 750 mL $23.45 Score: 91/100.

2003 Ch�teau Bouscass� AC Madiran, France – Southwest: Rich and round red wine with notes of mocha and blackcurrant. Pair with: steak, stew, roast. 743385 14% XD 750 mL $18.55 Score: 90/100.

2005 Botter Carlo Primitivo Doppio Passo I.G.T. Salento, Italy – Puglia: VC: This Primitivo (a.k.a. Zinfandel) is rich with aromas and flavors of dried fruit, blackcurrants and cherry. It is very concentrated, complex and nicely balanced by very soft tannins. The added intensity is achieved by the process called Doppio Passo, or double step. After the wine has been made, the winemakers add bunches of grapes that were left to dry to a raisin-like state on the vine. The resulting wine has increased richness and intensity. My note: This red wine is delicious, juicy and full-bodied, with aromas of ripe purple plums. Pair with: grilled steak, gourmet hamburgers. 60780 14% D 750 mL $14.45 Score: 87/100.

2004 Rizzuto Piconello Cabernet Sauvignon I.G.T. Sicilia, Italy – Sicily: A purple, lip-smacking and delicious wine. Pair with: BBQ, steak. 61523 13% XD 750 mL $15.85 Score: 87/100.

2005 Giovannella Stianti Castello Di Volpaia Chianti Classico D.O.C.G., Italy – Tuscany: VC: This blend of 90% Sangioveto, 10% Merlot and Syrah is fresh and aromatic with raspberry and strawberry dominating. A delicious Chianti that is ideal for enjoyment over the next half decade. My note: A delicious red wine with notes of mocha, coffee and black plums. Pair with: grilled lamb, lamb chops. 953828 13% XD 750 mL $22.45 Score: 90/100.

2005 Antinori P�ppoli Chianti Classico D.O.C.G., Italy – Tuscany: This full-bodied red wine has notes of spice and tart cherries. Also look for the full 750ml size below in these notes. 677328 13% XD 375 mL $12.85 Score: 88/100.

2006 Castiglioni Cabernet Sauvignon/Sangiovese I.G.T. Toscana, Italy – Tuscany: CV: This blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Sangiovese is a critically acclaimed consumer favorite. Its ripe, impactful nose serves up aromas of bold blackberry and toasty oak. Full-bodied, flavorful and nicely balanced by ripe tannins. My note: Juicy, mouth-watering, full-bodied red wine with aromas of cherries and oak. Pair with: lamb chops, lamb in mint sauce. 974394 13% XD 750 mL $22.95 Score: 89/100.

2005 Antinori P�ppoli Chianti Classico D.O.C.G., Italy – Tuscany: This full-bodied red wine has notes of spice and tart cherries. 606541 13% XD 750 mL $19.95 Score: 88/100.

2006 Soc. Agr. de Silgueiros Quinta Da Falorca Vinho Tinto DO D�o, Portugal: VC: A blend of Alfrocheiro, Tinta Roriz (a.k.a. Tempranillo) and Touriga Nacional, Quinta da Falorca Vinho Tinto is the perfect personification of the Portuguese style: forward fruit backed up by a good core of acid. My note: A full-bodied, lip-smacking, delicious wine of purple goodness. Pair with: braised beef. 67512 14% XD 750 mL $16.55 Score: 88/100.

2005 Dow/Symington Family Estates Vale Do Bomfim Reserva D.O.C. Douro, Portugal: A full-bodied red wine with aromas of black cherries and plums. Terrific value for this wine. 66944 13% D 750 mL $14.85 Score: 88/100.

2005 Fairview Shiraz WO Coastal Region, South Africa: Round, smooth and full-bodied wine with black fruit notes. Closed with a screwcap. Fantastic value. 626358 14% XD 750 mL $16.85 Score: 89/100.

2004 Rosell Mir Cabernet Sauvignon Subirats, D.O. Pened�s, Spain: VC: The Mir family have owned and operated this winery in the Pened�s since the 15th century. Medium deep ruby colour with aromas of cassis, cedar, underbrush and cherry. Dry with good fruit tones to start, leading to well-integrated mid-palate tannins and a good crisp acidity. Lingering finish. My note: A full-bodied and straight-forward wine with notes of black fruit. Pair with: grilled lamb, lamb chops. 60970 13% D 750 mL $18.45 Score: 87/100.

2005 Ironstone Vineyards Merlot Lodi, U.S.A. – California: VC: A terrific value for this bright and fruity merlot is well-balanced and food-friendly. It’s dry and medium-bodied, with a soft texture with clean plum and cherry flavors along with notes of licorice and vanilla. Enjoy with roasted pork, veal chops or a medium-rare steak. My note: This red wine is rich and round with notes of black fruit and mocha. Fantastic value! Pair with: roasted pork, veal chops, medium-rare steaks. 704353 13% D 750 mL $14.75 Score: 89/100.

2004 Rodney Strong Alden Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley, Sonoma, U.S.A. – California: VC: The Alden Vineyard sits at 1,200 feet (365 metres) above sea level. The location’s cooler temperatures and shorter growing season means smaller berries come picking time, resulting in flavors that are highly concentrated. As a result, the wine achieves an elegant balance between pure fruit flavors, acidity and tannin. Dark fruit and spice notes typify this high altitude Cab which can be enjoyed now or aged for up to 10 years. My note: A whopping big wine with aromas of mocha and blackberries 599795 14% XD 750 mL $39.80 Score: 90/100.

2004 Dominus Napa Valley, U.S.A. – California: A rich, full-bodied wine with notes of blackcurrant, cassis and smoke. Pair with: steak. 63487 14% XD 1500 mL $201.95 Score: 92/100.

2003 Columbia Crest Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Columbia Valley, United States: This red wine possesses aromas of mocha and black fruit. 56515 14% 750 mL $48.85 Score: 90/100.


Ros�s

2006 Familia Zuccardi Santa Julia Syrah Ros� Mendoza, Argentina: VC: Vibrant hot pink color. A real cha cha cha wine with aromas of blackberry, blueberry and strawberry, plus a hint of spice and pepper. It is ripe and dry with a sassy hint of bitterness on the finish. This wine will have you wanting to move to Latin rhythms. My note: Gorgeous and full-bodied, loads of fresh raspberry and berry fruits. Pair with: pulled pork, grilled lamb chops. 34322 12% D 750 mL $11.95 Score: 90/100.

2006 J. & F. Lurton Bodega Lurton Rosado Mendoza, Argentina: VC: This thirst quenching ros� comes from the Argentine outpost of Jacques and Francois Lurton’s wine empire. A blend of Bonarda, Malbec and Cabernet Sauvignon, this dazzling pink wine is bursting with berry fruit flavors balanced by a lively seam of acidity. It’s a superb summer sipper. My note: Gorgeous and full-bodied with loads of berry fruits. 999839 12% D 750 mL $11.95 Score: 90/100.

2006 Cave Spring Dry Ros� V.Q.A. Ontario - Niagara, Canada: Lovely, mouth-watering ros� with aromas of sweet raspberries and strawberries. Pair with: cold chicken, pat�, salmon, pasta salad or drink as an aperitif. 295006 12% 750 mL $13.15 Score: 89/100.

2006 Cousi�o-Macul Cabernet Sauvignon Ros� Maipo Valley, Chile: VC: This brilliant ros� is bursting with vibrant cherry and raspberry fruit flavors. Dry and juicy with a hint of melon, this lush, medium-bodied wine. My note: Mouth-watering and yummy! Chill it and serve by the lake. Pair with: salads, grilled salmon, chicken. 34314 14% D 750 mL $11.95 Score: 90/100.

2006 Les Ma�tres Vig. de la Presqu’lle St.-Tropez Saint-Tropez Carte Noire Ros� A.C. C�tes De Provence, France: An extremely light ros�. Light-bodied with faint aromas of strawberries. Pair with: spicy dishes, barbeque, curry, couscous. 319384 13% XD 750 mL $14.95 Score: 86/100.

2006 Domaine Maby La Forcadi�re Tavel AC, France - Provence: VC: According to Robert Parker Jr., Domaine Maby is a winery that ‘never disappoints’. Their ros�s are always anticipated because of their depth of flavor and beautiful balance of fruit and acid. My note: Lovely aromas of strawberries. Served chilled. Pair with: trout, bass. 701318 13% XD 750 mL $16.95 Score: 89/100.

2006 Chateau D'Aqueria Tavel Ros� AC, France - Rh�ne: VC: Hot pink color that speaks of summer. The aromas suggest raspberry, red pepper jelly, maraschino cherry and sweet lemon. Very dry with a touch of tannin, this ros� is medium-bodied with a good combination of acidity and fruit tones. My note: A gorgeous wine for a dry summer day. Aromas of raspberry and maraschino cherry. Pair with: barbecued salmon, chicken caesar salad, pork roast. 319368 13% XD 750 mL $19.95 Score: 90/100. Favorite Ros�


Sparkling Wine

Billecart-Salmon Brut Rose Champagne A.C., France: A muscular, full-bodied bubbly. Also available in 375 mL (924670, $47.95). 724559 12% XD 750 mL $84.95 Score: 92/100.

Rose Brut Non-Vintage Reims, France: The Lanson Rose Label is a blend of three champagne grape varieties: 32% chardonnay, 53% pinot noir, 15% pinot meunier. They are vinified in the traditional manner, small amount of quantity of pinot noir is vinified as red wine which gives the champagne its light salmon color. There are aromas of roses, raspberries on the nose. Pair with: white meat, fish. 12% D 750 mL $48.95 Score: 90/100.

2007 Georges Gardet Cuv�e Saint Flavy Brut Champagne, France: A bone-dry bubbly with notes of tart green apples. 924654 12% XD 750 mL $37.95 Score: 89/100.

Lanson Brut Ros� Champagne Rose Label AC, France - Champagne: A vibrant wine with aromas of strawberries and toast. 172130 12% XD 750 mL $54.95 Score: 90/100.

1999 Perrier-Jou�t Belle Epoque Champagne AC, France - Champagne: Lovely! Fresh, toasty notes with hints of green apples. One of the prettiest bottle designs for bubbly. 135798 XD 750 mL $129.95 Score: 90/100.

Taittinger Champagne Brut AC, France - Champagne: Lovely crisp aromas of green apples, citrus and toast. A lasting finish. Pair with: shellfish, seafood, fried foods or drink as an aperitif. 814723 750 mL $54.95 Score: 91/100.

1998 Pol Roger Chardonnay Brut Champagne AC, Extra Cuv�e De R�serve, France - Champagne: Fantastic warmth, toastiness and yeasty folds of flavor. Ripe pears and green apple aromas. Refreshing and zesty. If you haven't tried vintage-dated champagne, now's the time. Try the shabby-chic combo of bubbly and fried chicken or fish and chips ... new vistas of pleasure await you. Pair with: seafood, Asian curries, salads, vegetarian, deep fried anything. Drink: 2007-2012. 96685 XD 750 mL $79.95 Score: 92/100. Favorite Sparkling Wine


Dessert Wine

Fonseca Guimaraens Vinhos Fonseca Bin 27 Reserve Port Portugal: A gorgeous port with layers of warm, ripe plums and malts. Perfect to sip by the fire. 156877 20% S 750 mL $16.95 Score: 90/100.

2006 Trentham Estate La Famiglia Moscato Australia: VC: This Moscato is light and aromatic with lifted fruit characters and balanced sweetness. My note: A sweet, light wine with pleasing aromas of orange blossom. Pair with: roast pork, fruit based desserts. 43968 7% MS 750 mL $15.95 Score: 87/100.

2004 Pilliteri Estates Riesling Icewine Niagara, Canada: A lovely dessert option with notes of white peach, nectarine, white flowers and lemon zest. Tangerines and marmalade on the palate. Pair with: fruit salads, sabayon, biscotti. 53629 10% S 375 mL $50.00 Score: 91/100.

2005 Domaine Madeloc Banyuls Cirera A.C., France – Southwest: VC: Many consider Banyuls to be France's answer to Port. Made in a sweet, fortified style, it is rich and robust with tons of dried fruit, spice, raisin and vanilla aromas and flavors. My note: A lovely rich wine. Pair with: dark chocolate, milk chocolate. 48041 17% S 500 mL $25.85 Score: 90/100.

1997 Puklus Tokaji Szamorodni Dry Szentkereszt D�l�, Tokaj-Hegyalja, Hungary: VC: Szamorodni means “the way it was grown”. Since the botrytis-affected grapes are not separated from the bunches during the late-autumn harvest, the resulting wine will be either dry or sweet depending on the proportion of Asz� berries. My note: A wonderfully exotic white redolent of orange peel, rose petal and lychee. Pair with: rich seafood dishes, herbed chicken, Asian dishes. 48058 12% D 500 mL $13.85 Score: 87/100.

2004 Tommasi Vigneto Fiorato Recioto Della Valpolicella Doc, Italy – Veneto: VC: The deep dark red color of this Recioto leads to an intense nose of dried plums, cocoa and rose petals. The palate features a viscous backbone of baked plums and chocolate. The grapes underwent five months of ‘apassimento’ or drying before fermentation in temperature-controlled stainless steel vats. The wine is then aged in Slavonic oak barrels for one year prior to bottling. My note: A rich, luxurious dessert wine with aromas of jammy raspberries. Pair with: biscotti, panettone, black forest cake. 36236 13% MS 375 mL $26.95 Score: 90/100. Favorite Dessert Wine

Graham’s Six Grapes Reserve Port Portugal: A simple, purple and delicious wine. Great way to finish dinner. Pair with: nuts, chocolate-orange cake. 208405 20% S 750 mL $22.75 Score: 89/100.


To subscribe to Natalie's Wine Reviews, click here.

Residual Sugar Codes

XD = Extra Dry
D = Dry
MD = Medium Dry
M = Medium
S = Sweet

The residual sugar in wine (the amount left over after fermentation) may also be expressed numerically, with 0 for a completely dry wine, “1” stands for 1 gram of sugar per liter of wine for a wine with 0.1% residual sugar and ranging up to 25 grams/liter or more for a very sweet wine. Most dry-tasting red and white wines have residual sugar levels of 0, 1 or 2 or expressed alphabetically XD or D.

Product Codes

This is the multi-digit number noted just before the size of the bottle to identify it. Product codes are used LCBO stores and several other chains, but not everywhere. They are different from the UPC code which is scanned at check-out.

Nat Decants 100-Point Scale

95-100 Brilliant, Exceptional
90-94 Excellent, Superb
89.5 Hovering on the doorstep of excellence, better than very good
85-89 Very Good
80-84 Good (still worth buying and drinking)
79 and below Average to poor (I don't include these in the newsletter due to space constraints)

Favorite Wines: This isn't necessarily the wine with the highest score, as high scores go to the wines that best typify their region and style. Rather my favorite wines are just that: the ones that appeal to me most personally and to my own taste.

Best Value Wines: Not necessarily the cheapest wine, but the one that maximizes the price-quality ratio. (Although I don't always go by strict mathematical ratios on this either, but rather what seems to me to represent tremendous value.)

For more details on how I do my wine reviews and tips on how to find these wines click here. To find dishes to match these wines, click here.


Comments? Suggestions? If you'd like to receive Natalie's free e-wine newsletter, sign up at www.nataliemaclean.com. It's free and your e-mail address will be kept confidential.

Copyright © 2008 by Natalie MacLean. All rights reserved. Please ask permission of the author before copying or using this material.